Exemplary Feedback

The Definition of Exemplary

1. Worthy of imitation; commendable.
2. Serving as a model.

The Exemplary Feedback system attempts to encourage detailed, constructive feedback in submissions.

Benefits of Exemplary Feedback

  • The post is made prominent in the feedback area by a green tick icon.
  • Points are awarded to the poster.

How to attain Exemplariness

You can attain exemplariness by making detailed, honest but polite feedback and testing a submission before assessing it. Don't be afraid to give a hard assessment, as provided your feedback is justified, you have a higher chance of achieving exemplariness. Moderators should read the Exemplary Feedback ModDoc for guidelines on bestowing exemplariness.

By tom 5 years ago 130 posts 18,831 views

Comments

  • MC rex's Levels
    • P2: Drudge
      Points: 3,386
    • E1: Helper
      EF: 1
    • C1: Member
    • A3: Apprentice
      Account Age: 1 year
    MC rex

    So, feedback has to be long to be considered Exemplary? So, even if something is memorable, and serves as a model, its screwed if it isin't 100 lines long?

    • Agree x 5
    • Funny x 1
    • Dumb x 1
    • Disagree x 1
    • wtf x 1
    • Helpful x 4
    • Rude x 1
    • Win x 1
    • Thanks x 1
    User Title
    Bleh
  • Hells High's Levels
    • P2: Drudge
      Points: 2,340
    • E1: Helper
      EF: 11
    • C2: Ripe Member
    • A5: Veteran
      Account Age: 5 years
    Hells High

    I'm always trying to give people the best feedback from my perspective as possible. I see no merit in posting "this sucks" on someone's WIP or submission. (Unless, of course, it is entirely tasteless and goes against the rules or something like that).

    It might be bad, sure, but posting something helpful and giving them some direction or advice just seems so much more... Proper? Helpful? I dunno.

    • Agree x 2
    User Title
    Aminatoar
  • tom's Levels
    • P2: Drudge
      Points: 4,189
    • E1: Helper
      EF: 2
    • C6: Super Admin
    • A7: Legend
      Account Age: 11 years
    tom

    Posted by Hanzo Sixx

    Lol, I meant that I have seen the posts that have already been, but I'll keep my eyes out for them.

    Ohh ok :) Thanks mate

    testing 1 2 3 4
  • Hanzo Sixx's Levels
    • P1: Beggar
      Points: 860
    • C1: Member
    • A4: Graduate
      Account Age: 3 years
    Hanzo Sixx

    Posted by tom

    Posted by Hanzo Sixx

    I think this system of critquing politely but still giving the harsh reality to people that, honestly you might not be that good, and that you need to improve on this this and this. I have seen many of the exemplary feedback comments. All of them deserving such a reward after reading them. I'm surprised that it has been six months and no one other person aside Poux, and yourself tom have posted to this. So, on behalf of all those who have received such a post of great polite detail: Thank you.

    If you see posts that are worthy you should notify a mod!

    Lol, I meant that I have seen the posts that have already been, but I'll keep my eyes out for them.

    User Title
    Burn, Baby burn Shes a witch!
  • tom's Levels
    • P2: Drudge
      Points: 4,189
    • E1: Helper
      EF: 2
    • C6: Super Admin
    • A7: Legend
      Account Age: 11 years
    tom

    Posted by Hanzo Sixx

    I think this system of critquing politely but still giving the harsh reality to people that, honestly you might not be that good, and that you need to improve on this this and this. I have seen many of the exemplary feedback comments. All of them deserving such a reward after reading them. I'm surprised that it has been six months and no one other person aside Poux, and yourself tom have posted to this. So, on behalf of all those who have received such a post of great polite detail: Thank you.

    If you see posts that are worthy you should notify a mod!

    testing 1 2 3 4
  • Hanzo Sixx's Levels
    • P1: Beggar
      Points: 860
    • C1: Member
    • A4: Graduate
      Account Age: 3 years
    Hanzo Sixx

    I think this system of critquing politely but still giving the harsh reality to people that, honestly you might not be that good, and that you need to improve on this this and this. I have seen many of the exemplary feedback comments. All of them deserving such a reward after reading them. I'm surprised that it has been six months and no one other person aside Poux, and yourself tom have posted to this. So, on behalf of all those who have received such a post of great polite detail: Thank you.

    User Title
    Burn, Baby burn Shes a witch!
  • tom's Levels
    • P2: Drudge
      Points: 4,189
    • E1: Helper
      EF: 2
    • C6: Super Admin
    • A7: Legend
      Account Age: 11 years
    tom

    Posted by Frizz925

    There's no comment posted here :3

    Nice :)

    testing 1 2 3 4
  • Frizz925's Levels
    • E1: Helper
      EF: 5
    • C1: Member
    • A4: Graduate
      Account Age: 3 years
    Frizz925

    There's no comment posted here :3

    • Dumb x 1
    *Switching to the old account*

SubFeed